On the 9th of May, I attended
Australia’s first service-learning summit in Brisbane. It was one jam-packed day of lively discussions and engaging presentations. I left feeling very excited about service-learning’s future in Australia.
Barbara Holland, a service-learning guru and keynote speaker, kicked things off by talking about four themes:
- knowledge and knowledge gaps about service-learning,
- how service-learning contributes to student learning outcomes,
- the importance of building equitable partnerships,
- service-learning compared to work-integrated learning.
She situated service-learning in the middle of
Furco’s spectrum of experiential learning (1996), and put “community and service” on one side and “student and learning” on the other to demonstrate that it’s a balanced approach.

Furco (1996) Service-learning: A balanced approach
After building some context around service-learning, first globally, then locally, she drew some interesting comparisons between service-learning and work-integrated learning. Commenting that the two have similar values, in that they are more integral ways of connecting theory and practice than, say, an internship, which is more separated from a class. But they both have the benefit of some interaction happening outside of the classroom. This is important because when you look at the Australian Employability Skills Framework, you wonder how students can possibly develop some of the skills listed in a classroom environment. To further stir the pot, she noted that “social responsibility” is missing from that framework.
All of this made me think of “place” and “space” as it relates to service-learning. Michel de Certeau (1984) and
Yi-Fu Tuan (1977) discuss these concepts as important to making meaning out of everyday life. I personally think Tuan’s description is more relevant to service-learning. From Tuan’s perspective (humanistic geography), place can be regarded as providing security. It makes us feel rooted. Whereas space speaks to our desire for freedom to explore, to move around, to feel engaged. Most people seek a balance between the two. But… sometimes we want more of one than the other, which results in tensions or may lead to a change.
In class, even though seats are not assigned, I often see students sitting in the same place, week after week, throughout a semester. (I was guilty of this too when I was in school.) That place must give them a sense of security; it’s comfortable. But if all of their learning happened from that one place, then they would be missing out — on conversations and relationships with new people. Another level of learning can emerge when you interact with others who are unlike you. And that’s a beautiful thing about service-learning. It takes you out of your comfort zone and makes you think about others.
Anyways… back to the conference… The SL and WIL comparison was interesting. Some people felt that the two were very much the same. Most of us agreed on one difference: work-integrated learning is transactional (focused on developing professional skills) and service-learning is transformational (focused more on affective skills like ethics and empathy).
Barbara firmly believes that the #1 focus, before starting any service-learning activity, should be the learning goal. Always ask yourself, as a teacher, “what do you want the students to learn?”
The last point worth noting, that both Barbara Holland and
Dr. Carol Nicoll (CEO of the ALTC) hit on, is the need for infrastructure (e.g. systems, funding) and leadership (both from institutions and the government) to support these efforts. How do we get that support? While warm ‘n fuzzy success stories do matter, Carol firmly believes that it will take an evidence-based approach to demonstrate the impact that service-learning has on students and the community.