Design students partner with a local homeless shelter

During the spring semester of 2014, students in Design Methodologies worked with St. Francis House, St. Augustine’s only emergency shelter serving the homeless and less fortunate, to create a new identity for the organization. Each student created a logo and stationery package. The logo designed by Kara Walter was chosen to form the basis of the branding campaign.

IMG_1798.JPG

The entire class continued the service-learning project by each creating part of a suite of marketing pieces, including an informational handout (designed by Miranda Lee), a promotional media folder, posters, a banner, t-shirts, social media profiles and much more.

IMG_1797.PNG

“The students learned a great deal from the experience, and I did too,” said Stephenson. “Since we visited the shelter and saw first-hand the facilities, the people and the administrative offices, this became so much more than just another class project. It was real and very meaningful for us.”

“We were so excited about the opportunity to work with these talented students,” said Judy Dembowski, Executive Director of St. Francis House. “We are deeply grateful for the amazing work the students have done. The results exceeded our wildest dreams. Every student put their heart into this project. The results meet or exceed what we could have gotten, but could never have afforded, at an established agency. Every student in this class has a promising career ahead of them.”

IMG_1799.PNG

Their work will help the organization launch a new identity as St. Francis House celebrates 30 years serving those in need.

Are student-run design agencies a form of service-learning?

I’ve stumbled upon several student-run design agencies during my research. Some of these agencies charge for creative services, but many of them provide pro-bono design to on-campus and nonprofit organizations in their local communities. Since they are faculty-led initiatives (i.e. structured learning), I see the pro-bono agencies as a form of service-learning in design education. Do you agree?

I decided to start a list, to see what can be learned from the models that universities have developed. While searching for student-run design agencies, I found several full-service communications agencies that attract students from advertising, public relations and graphic design. I also discovered A Professional Project Surveying Student-Run Advertising and Public Relations Agencies at Institutions with ACEJMC Accredited Programs. According to Busch (2013), 54 agencies exist at institutions with ACEJMC accredited programs in Journalism and Mass Communications in the United States. The project reviewed 40 of these agencies, noting the founding date, services offered, agency structure, financial structure, and clientele.

The list below is by no means comprehensive. It includes agencies that have an online presence. Please let me know if you are aware of a design agency that’s not on this list. If you are planning to start an agency at your institution, I hope this collection is helpful.

Student-run design agencies that provide pro-bono services:

Mix of free and fee:

  • Binghamton Student Design Agency
    http://www.binghamtonsda.org
    They provide pro-bono design for on-campus organizations and charge an hourly rate for local businesses.

Student design agencies that charge for creative services:

  • Princeton University’s agency, SDA
    http://www.princetonsda.com
    They have an impressive print and web portfolio. They do charge for design (see their Rates page), but they offer free workshops on Saturdays that cover “design principles and software tips.”
    Princeton_Spring_CleanUp
  • University of Pennsylvania’s agency PSD
    http://www.pennstudentdesign.com/
    They provide “the University community, affiliated organizations, and the greater Philadelphia area with quality creative and design services at affordable rates.” Student groups receive a discount.

Student-run advertising agencies:

Eggstra credit

I often incorporate service-learning projects into my graphic design classes. They typically last the whole semester, with some planning beforehand and then a bit of housekeeping after the semester concludes. While very rewarding, let’s be honest, they are a lot of work. If you don’t have the time to coordinate a full-scale, semester-long, service-learning project, then perhaps you can try something like this…

Card design by Ben Cronin

In March, I contacted the Student Government’s Community Service Committee to see if they had any design needs, and they did. They were planning to make “get well” cards for patients at the local hospital. Instead of using blank, store-bought cards, we thought that students in my classes could design spring-themed cards. I offered this as an extra credit opportunity and received about a dozen different designs. Approximately 17 copies of each card design were printed and distributed to the 200 or so patients on Easter. Hopefully, the students’ creativity lifted some spirits that day…

While this engagement wasn’t nearly as involved as most service-learning projects that I’ve been a part of, it was good experience for the students. They were using their talents to do something nice for people (giving), and they got a little exposure at the same time (receiving). It was completely voluntary (about one third of the class participated), whereas most academic service-learning is offered as compulsory class projects. And, from an instructor’s point of view, it was fairly quick and easy to coordinate.

The art of companionship

Leslie Robison, a professor in the Art Department at Flagler College, recently taught a class titled “Relational Art”. I was intrigued by the title of this subject, especially after receiving the invitation to attend the art exhibition. The invitation mentioned that this was an intergenerational collaboration between Flagler Art Students and the Council on Aging. The show was called “The Buddy System: The Art of Companionship”.

Here’s how it worked. At the beginning of the semester, students were partnered with older adults. Throughout the semester, they got to know one another and created works of art together.

I was able to attend the show, and one piece really touched me. The student had created a wooden model of her partner’s home. This physical artifact acted like a memory trigger and storage facility. He could write down memories and put them in the house. What a beautiful idea, eh?

This got me thinking… with service-learning in design education, many times the “partner” is a non-profit organization and the “project” is an advertising campaign, a logo, a poster or an annual report. The “service” is graphic design. The direct beneficiary is the organization. There’s little to no contact with the actual community members. So how much of the work that students are doing is really impacting the community? It seems that students are one step removed from that level of engagement.

If you view the “buddy system” as a service-learning project, the partner organization was the Council on Aging, but the service was not art; it was companionship. And isn’t that a beautiful thing? Can “service” in graphic design programs be more than students providing pro-bono creative services for clients? Can it also involve relationships with people in the community (buddy system), skills transfer (Hip Hop Haven), etc? What more can we do with these opportunities?

Australia’s first service-learning summit

On the 9th of May, I attended Australia’s first service-learning summit in Brisbane. It was one jam-packed day of lively discussions and engaging presentations. I left feeling very excited about service-learning’s future in Australia.

Barbara Holland, a service-learning guru and keynote speaker, kicked things off by talking about four themes:

  • knowledge and knowledge gaps about service-learning,
  • how service-learning contributes to student learning outcomes,
  • the importance of building equitable partnerships,
  • service-learning compared to work-integrated learning.
She situated service-learning in the middle of Furco’s spectrum of experiential learning (1996), and put “community and service” on one side and “student and learning” on the other to demonstrate that it’s a balanced approach.

Furco (1996) Service-learning: A balanced approach

After building some context around service-learning, first globally, then locally, she drew some interesting comparisons between service-learning and work-integrated learning. Commenting that the two have similar values, in that they are more integral ways of connecting theory and practice than, say, an internship, which is more separated from a class. But they both have the benefit of some interaction happening outside of the classroom. This is important because when you look at the Australian Employability Skills Framework, you wonder how students can possibly develop some of the skills listed in a classroom environment. To further stir the pot, she noted that “social responsibility” is missing from that framework.

All of this made me think of “place” and “space” as it relates to service-learning. Michel de Certeau (1984) and Yi-Fu Tuan (1977) discuss these concepts as important to making meaning out of everyday life. I personally think Tuan’s description is more relevant to service-learning. From Tuan’s perspective (humanistic geography), place can be regarded as providing security. It makes us feel rooted. Whereas space speaks to our desire for freedom to explore, to move around, to feel engaged. Most people seek a balance between the two. But… sometimes we want more of one than the other, which results in tensions or may lead to a change.

In class, even though seats are not assigned, I often see students sitting in the same place, week after week, throughout a semester. (I was guilty of this too when I was in school.) That place must give them a sense of security; it’s comfortable. But if all of their learning happened from that one place, then they would be missing out — on conversations and relationships with new people. Another level of learning can emerge when you interact with others who are unlike you. And that’s a beautiful thing about service-learning. It takes you out of your comfort zone and makes you think about others.

Anyways… back to the conference… The SL and WIL comparison was interesting. Some people felt that the two were very much the same. Most of us agreed on one difference: work-integrated learning is transactional (focused on developing professional skills) and service-learning is transformational (focused more on affective skills like ethics and empathy).

Barbara firmly believes that the #1 focus, before starting any service-learning activity, should be the learning goal. Always ask yourself, as a teacher, “what do you want the students to learn?”

The last point worth noting, that both Barbara Holland and Dr. Carol Nicoll (CEO of the ALTC) hit on, is the need for infrastructure (e.g. systems, funding) and leadership (both from institutions and the government) to support these efforts. How do we get that support? While warm ‘n fuzzy success stories do matter, Carol firmly believes that it will take an evidence-based approach to demonstrate the impact that service-learning has on students and the community.

We’ve got 99 problems but a beach ain’t one

I recently learned that Maryland Institute College of Art is now offering a Master of Arts in social design. While reading the bios of faculty involved in this new program, I discovered Project M and had to share.

In their own words, Project M is “an assembly of young designers on a mission to use their creativity for the greater good. Rogue by nature, Project M teaches designers to “think wrong” about the things that matter most in our world and then act.” Each summer a team of young designers, writers, photographers and advisors assemble to tackle a different problem/project.

The 2010 Project M South team went to Greensboro, Alabama to witness firsthand the devastation caused by the BP oil spill. After visiting the coast, the team designed a range of material that highlights some of the issues and implications surrounding this catastrophe. For example, a poster (available for purchase) reads “We’ve got 99 problems but a beach ain’t one.” In addition to the designed components, Project M encourages people to take action — send a message to President Obama, donate to charities or reduce oil consumption.

The project’s mission this year was “to bring light to the lack of media transparency covering the deep water horizon oil spill, the BP stronghold in the cleanup efforts, and what might be if we don’t start changing our behavior towards oil dependency.”

The work done by Project M demonstrates the impact that a small team of designers can have. As Margaret Meade is known to have said, “Never underestimate the power of a few committed people to change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.”

Animations of Hidden Voices

Today, I ran across a series of animations by design students at North Carolina State University created in an effort to raise awareness of homelessness. The project, which was part of the Advanced Media Lab program at NC State, was done in collaboration with Hidden Voices, a nonprofit organization in the community. The staff at Hidden Voices was developing an even larger project to share creative work, like writings and performances, by homeless people living in Orange County. The students from NC State were asked to create interpretive animations of recorded conversations with homeless individuals. Students explored various ways to visualize stories that focused on “medical bankruptcy, mental health conditions, domestic violence, foster children aging out of support systems, parental rejection of gay and lesbian teens and poverty.”

Some incredible and powerful work resulted and has been shown at the Chapel Hill Public Arts Office. Three chapters are also available on YouTube. Animations from chapter one are below.

Special Issue of IJD: Designing for Services

I recently learned that the International Journal of Design’s latest call for papers is focused on “Designing for Services“. That was a bitter-sweet discovery. Sweet, because it demonstrates the growth and strength of service design globally. Bitter, because I found out about it a bit too late to submit anything and it won’t be published until August 2011. A long drumroll…

Not only is the focus on service design, but SD that emphasizes a human-centered design approach. Articles will address one of the four themes: the design of service encounters, service design for small and medium-sized enterprises, co-creation in service design, and service design for organizational change.

I can’t wait to read this issue!

What will it mean to be a designer in 2015?

We can’t know for sure, but one thing is certain, a graphic designer in 2015 will be faced with different challenges than a graphic designer in 2010.

A few years ago, AIGA and Adobe partnered up to investigate some emerging trends in design so that they could “help prepare designers for the skills and roles that will be expected of them” in the near future. After conducting research, which included focus groups, interviews, workshops and surveys, gathering feedback from nearly 2,500 people, they attempted to define the designer of 2015.

Thirteen competencies that a successful designer should display were identified.

These include the ability to:

  1. develop a visual response to a communication problem,
  2. identify and solve real problems,
  3. understand broadly the issues related to the context,
  4. respond to the audience’s needs,
  5. utilize tools and technology appropriately,
  6. be flexible, nimble and dynamic in practice,
  7. communicate productively in interdisciplinary teams,
  8. understand how systems behave,
  9. construct verbal arguments for solutions that address diverse audiences, lifespan issues, and business operations,
  10. understand cultural preservation in a global environment,
  11. collaborate productively in large teams,
  12. practice ethically,
  13. understand cause-effect relationships and develop evaluation criteria that account for audience and context

The results of this study could have quite an impact on design education. I wonder… To what extent does the integration of service-learning in undergraduate design education develop students’ skill in the thirteen competencies identified by Adobe and the AIGA? This is an important question that I’m exploring in my research.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free